Vegan Activist 5: Doing More Harm Than Good?

October 24, 2019

Vegan Activist 5: Doing more harm than good? - Leafy Souls Vegan Blog Post

Veganism has long been considered a worthy ethical lifestyle choice, and many believe it has finally entered the mainstream. But are extreme anti-meat tactics doing more harm than good?

Veganism, they tell us, has gone mainstream. It’s no longer a fringe movement reserved for hippies and Hare Krishnas; even Beyoncé is singing the praises of a plant-based diet. Whether exposing the public to graphic footage of animal slaughter or storming steakhouses chanting ‘there’s no excuse for animal abuse’, the point of confrontational vegan activism is to persuade people to become vegan. Or at least reduce meat consumption.

This strategy of building consumer demand for veganism is itself ineffective. Veganism is a new market for capital to exploit in its perpetually expanding scope of accumulation, but no substitute for the considerable profits of animal agriculture. Within capitalism, more vegan options will never mean any meat.

Transforming Global Systems

Eliminating the use of animals for food will require fundamentally transforming global economic and agricultural systems to work for human and non-human animals, not profit. Shifts of such historic magnitude require mass political movements. But the tactics of confrontational vegan activism restrict the possibility of such a movement emerging.

Their narratives construe veganism as a moral red-line – justified by ecological breakdown’s immediacy and/or animals’ right to life – alienating and excluding from that movement so many with deep, legitimate cultural commitments to eating meat. Capitalism makes it impossible to live and consume with total moral purity. Producing activist cultures requiring so much of participants means shooting ourselves in the foot before the marathon begins.

Activism is Misdirected

It is right that successful social movements confront the status quo and dominant narratives. However, by focusing on ordinary people’s behaviors vegan activists’ target is misdirected. If our ambition is to transform our food system, our target must be governments and corporations propping up business-as-usual. Our terrain of struggle must also move beyond just changing hearts, minds, and specific laws, and towards advancing proposals and demands for structural alternatives.

In one sense it's understandable to have that type of emotional reaction, but if someone is doing egregious harm, the goal is to find an effective way to get the harm to stop. 

But there are good reasons for thinking that extreme methods are counterproductive. This includes some non-violent acts, such as vegan protestors storming a Melbourne steakhouse shouting anti-meat slogans in the dining area earlier this year.

One of the challenges facing anti-meat advocates is that the consumption of animals is so deeply ingrained in our culture.

Of course, the fact that a practice is pervasive in society does not imply that it is morally acceptable. But the less common a moral view is, the more likely its proponents will be dismissed as kooks who don't deserve to be taken seriously.

And while vegan and vegetarian diets are growing in popularity, the position that consumption of animal products is a heinous act is still a minority view. This makes it easier for meat eaters to ignore the arguments and to stereotype vegans as self-righteous virtue signallers. When animal activists decide to vandalize, intimidate, and harass, this only exacerbates the problem.

Leave a comment

Also in Leafy Souls' Vegan Blog

Celebrity Vegan Fashion - Leafy Souls Vegan Blog
Celebrity Vegan Fashion

November 14, 2019

At the 2018 Met Gala, Cyrus chose to wear Stella McCartney, one of the pioneers in vegan and sustainable fashion. In an interview with Vogue, Cyrus called for the fashion industry to make the change, as fabulous fashion doesn't have to mean torture.
Read More
Mena Suvari Vegan Fashion - leafy Souls Vegan Blog
Mena Suvari Vegan Fashion

November 13, 2019

Mena Suvari, the actress known for both “American Woman” and “American Beauty,” was in the front row at last week’s first Vegan Fashion Week at the California Market Center, wearing a black textured patent-something cap with matching jacket and pants by Enda, along with “leather” shoes by a brand that bore the label Cult of Coquette.
Read More
Vegan Fashion Show UK - Leafy Souls Vegan Blog
Vegan Fashion Show UK

November 12, 2019

There are now over half a million vegans living in Britain – it’s one of the fastest-growing movements for people seeking to embrace a more ethical, environmentally friendly way of life. It informs how we consume every day and the question of choice is now helping to drive fabric development and innovation within the fashion industry.
Read More
Sizing Guide

In this guide you can see the detailed sizing charts to all our products

Unisex Tshirts

Width, in 19 21 23 25 27 29 31 33
Length, in 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36
Sleeve length, in 8 8 9 9 10 10 11 11


Width, cm 47 52.1 57.2 62.2 67.3 72.4 77.5 82.6
Length, cm 72.4 74.9 77.5 80 82.6 85.1 87.6 90.2
Sleeve length, cm 18.4 19.7 20.9 22.2 23.5 24.8 26 27.3


Women's Tees:

Width, in 17 18 19 20 22
Length, in 26 26 27 28 28
Sleeve length, in 7 8 8 8 8



Width, cm 41.2 43.8 46.3 50.2 54
Length, cm 64.4 66 67.6 69.2 70.8
Sleeve length, cm 17.3 17.9 18.5 19.1 19.7




Sleeve length, in 25 25 25 25 25 25 27 27
Length, in 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34
Width, in 20 23 24 26 28 30 33 34


Sleeve length, cm 62.9 62.9 62.9 62.9 62.9 62.9 67.9 67.9
Length, cm 68.5 71.1 73.6 76.2 78.7 81.2 83.8 86.3
Width, cm 50.8 55.9 60.9 66 71.1 76.2 81.3 86.3